I Turned the Domino’s Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza into a Wisconsin 25 Cheese Pizza!

Delicious Wisconsin cheeseThere are a lot of people out there who have a “bucket list,” or a list of things they want to do before they die. I have a similar list, with the only difference being that my list involves things I want to write about on my blog at some point. One item has been at the very top of that list for over a year now, and last weekend I finally made it a reality.

You see, a little over a year ago Domino’s announced the Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza, which is topped with mozzarella, feta, Provolone, Cheddar, Parmesan and Asiago cheese. Ever since then I’ve had the crazy idea of buying as many other Wisconsin cheeses as I could find, shredding them up and turning the Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza into something crazy like a Wisconsin 20 Cheese Pizza.

The problem with my idea, and the reason it didn’t come to fruition any earlier than it did, was that I didn’t really know of any grocery stores or cheese shops that I could go to and buy small quantities of every single Wisconsin cheese that they had without them getting extremely annoyed with me. Then I was introduced to a shop in Madison, Wisconsin called Fromagination that sells “cheese orphans.” What are cheese orphans you ask? Basically, when a wheel of cheese is cut there are a bunch of smaller sized pieces of cheese left over that each weigh in at around 1/5 of a pound. In other words, they were absolutely perfect for my pizza!

Armed with a bunch of cheese orphans from Fromagination, a few different cheeses that I already had in my refrigerator and a few more that I picked up at my local grocery store I grabbed my cheese shredder and got to work. When it was all said and done I had spent almost an hour shredding a total of 19 different cheeses into what turned out to be a towering six pound pile of dairy delight. I then placed a call to Domino’s and ordered a large Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza.

When the Domino’s delivery driver showed up at my house 35 minutes later with my pizza I couldn’t wait to open it up. I’d never even tried the Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza until then, so I was anxious to check it out. Looking inside the box however I was actually a little disappointed with the amount of cheese on the pizza. Even though it contained six different cheeses it didn’t really even seem like it had any more cheese than a regular pizza, which I sort of expected it to. Luckily I had six pounds of shredded cheese to add to it!

After piling the 19 additional cheeses onto my pizza (which ended up measuring almost three inches in height) I put it back into the oven and awaited with eager anticipation as the cheese melted. After about twelve minutes my pizza was ready to slice into. I immediately ran into a problem however as my pizza cutter was completely useless when it came time to slice through all the added cheese. My semi-crisis was easily averted however when I grabbed a pie knife and instead used that to slice through my pizza and dish myself out a piece of the gooey goodness.

The crazy amount of cheese on my pizza made it extremely greasy, and nearly impossible to eat without using a knife and fork, but overall it actually wasn’t too bad. Considering the varying flavors of all the different cheeses on the pizza I actually expected it to taste terrible, but that wasn’t the case at all. Granted, it was WAY too much cheese to eat more than two slices in a sitting, but everything actually blended together fairly well. The fact that the eight slices weighed in at over 3/4 of a pound each was also pretty detrimental when it came to finishing this pizza, but after five separate meals the Wisconsin 25 Cheese Pizza was no more!

Would I make the pizza again? Probably not. Not because it wasn’t good, but mainly because buying six pounds of various fancy Wisconsin cheeses is sort of expensive. Either way though, I’m glad that I can finally cross the Wisconsin 25 Cheese Pizza off my blog bucket list! Next up on my list? The McEverything, which basically involves me going to McDonald’s, buying every single menu item they have and combining it all into one ridiculous sandwich.

Oh yeah, and for all you foodies out there wondering which 19 Wisconsin cheeses I added to my pizza here’s a complete list, along with the names of the companies that produce them:

  • 2 Year Aged Cheddar (Widmer’s Cheese Cellars)
  • 3 Year Aged Cheddar (Roelli Cheese Haus)
  • 4 Year Aged Cheddar (Widmer’s Cheese Cellars)
  • Aged Brick (Widmer’s Cheese Cellars)
  • Bandaged Cheddar (Bleu Mont Dairy)
  • Caso Bolo (Carr Valley Cheese Company)
  • Chocolate Cheese Fudge (Sugar Brook Farms)
  • Colby (Henning’s Cheese)
  • Dunbarton Blue (Roelli Cheese Haus)
  • Eagle Creek Reserve (Meister Cheese Company)
  • Fresh Mozzarella (Crave Brothers Farmstead Cheese)
  • Gran Queso (Roth Kase Cellars)
  • Marieke Gouda Foenegreek (Holland Family Cheese)
  • Pleasant Ridge Reserve (Uplands Cheese Company)
  • Red Rock (Roelli Cheese Haus)
  • Rush Creek Reserve (Uplands Cheese Company)
  • Seasonal Fall Cheddar (Otter Creek Organic Farm)
  • Wisconsin Colby Jack (DeMill)
  • Wisconsin Swiss (DeMill)

14 Comments on I Turned the Domino’s Wisconsin 6 Cheese Pizza into a Wisconsin 25 Cheese Pizza!

  1. Amanda
    December 12, 2011 at 2:54 pm (3 years ago)

    I bet if you told the cheesemongers what you were doing with that cheese they would die a little bit inside. I asked them for a good cheese for pizza once and they told me (in a nice way!) that Fromagination cheeses are better suited for a fancy cheese tray versus a pizza. Oh well!

    Reply
    • Nick
      December 12, 2011 at 4:17 pm (3 years ago)

      Ha ha ha. If they didn’t even want ONE of their cheeses on a pizza then they’re certainly not going to be happy about this!

      Reply
      • Amanda
        December 19, 2011 at 3:49 pm (3 years ago)

        I also love the fact that they leftovers of the cheese wheel are called “orphans”. Makes me feel like I’m doing a good deed by giving them a good home! :)

        Reply
        • Nick
          December 19, 2011 at 4:04 pm (3 years ago)

          Ha ha ha. I totally thought the same thing!

          Reply
  2. Zach
    December 13, 2011 at 12:43 am (3 years ago)

    This is absolutely absurd, but it looks so delicious.

    Reply
  3. sam
    December 13, 2011 at 6:46 am (3 years ago)

    ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer but i do have to ask… did you really put choco-cheesy fudge on a pizza??

    Reply
    • Nick
      December 13, 2011 at 10:01 am (3 years ago)

      I did! Not a ton of it though, and since there was so much other cheese its taste didn’t overpower the pizza or anything. The chocolate cheese fudge is actually super good. I’ll have another blog post coming up at some point where I use the fudge cheese as well.

      Reply
  4. Ashley
    December 14, 2011 at 12:34 pm (3 years ago)

    As unappealing as that much cheese sounds to me I still sort of want to taste it.

    Reply
  5. Milweb1
    December 17, 2011 at 9:50 am (3 years ago)

    Being lactose intolerance, this would kill me. But I still want a slice..

    Reply
  6. Kim
    August 19, 2012 at 8:05 pm (2 years ago)

    Ya got an iron stomach Dude! ^^

    Reply
  7. elizabeth
    November 14, 2012 at 5:37 pm (2 years ago)

    A thing of beauty!!!!

    Reply
  8. elizabeth
    November 14, 2012 at 5:45 pm (2 years ago)

    Dude….How expensive was all the cheese???What was the final cost?

    Reply
    • Nick
      November 14, 2012 at 5:52 pm (2 years ago)

      I don’t really remember, but probably somewhere in the $50 range, ha ha.

      Reply
  9. Kozi
    April 11, 2013 at 7:07 pm (1 year ago)

    I love you. ;_;

    This is a miracle.

    Reply

Leave a Reply